“Can we schedule the toy session when my kids aren’t home?” a client of mine once asked.
She wasn’t alone. Many parents feel they can declutter faster without their children’s pushback, or the sudden moment when every toy in the house becomes a favorite.
For years, I would have said, “Of course.” Then, at some point, I realized I was doing my clients a disservice.
The toys left faster, but the power struggle stayed.
That’s what drew me to the work of Sinem Hallı. She writes through three lenses: a mother with a background in child development, an industrial designer who looks closely at how toys function in homes and affect families, and a researcher who studies how we make purchasing decisions around toys.
Together, we explored what happens when a child and a parent see the same toy differently, and who should get the final say on which ones stay or go.
Here’s our conversation:
Ann: Toys are supposed to be fun, but when there are too many of them, they become a source of friction for families. Parents are often the ones cleaning up, looking for misplaced toys, and breaking up fights over the same toy.
Parents also decide which toys come into the home, and they’re often the ones paying for them. So when toys pile up to the point of overwhelm, break, or are outgrown, who do you think gets to decide what happens next?
Sinem: One thing I notice, both as a mother and through my work with toys, is that adults can become much stricter when it is time for children’s things to leave the house.
We say, “This is taking up space,” or “You do not use this anymore,” and we are ready to let it go. There is an interesting tension here.
Designers create more things and, however good our intentions are, the market still rewards selling more. Parents eventually want some of those things out of the house. And very often, the person who wants to keep them is the child.
That makes me pause. Once an object has entered a child’s world, I think the decision about letting it go should mainly belong to the child. The parent can help, ask questions, and understand why something matters. But unless there is a reason related to safety or health, I would be very careful about deciding for them.
Ann: When parents make the decision without any input from their kids, or sneak things out of the home, power struggles follow. Children can also lose trust and a sense of safety when the few things they can call their own simply disappear.
I see two extremes. Some adults who didn’t have a say about their belongings as children now hold on tightly to everything. Others repeat the cycle, clearing out their children’s things the way theirs once were.
At the same time, I understand parents who feel bombarded by the visual noise. Without the time, energy, or skills to manage it all, they may feel they have no choice but to set rules like “If you leave it out, it’s gone.”
So when a child’s things end up all over the house, or in the parents’ spaces, does that give parents the right to take them away?
Sinem: I actually find it very natural that children leave parts of themselves wherever the family spends time.
Children usually want to be close to their parents. So if the parent is in the living room, the child often brings their play there too. We accept that the sofa, the dining table, or the chair belongs in the shared family space. I think children also want something of theirs to exist there.
Our living room is currently almost completely taken over by my son. We sometimes feel like we are the guests there. But he is also a member of the household, so it does not feel strange to me.
Telling a child, “Go and play only in your room,” has never felt very equal to me. Their belongings spreading into shared spaces can also be a way of saying, “I live here too.”
Ann: Children definitely prefer to play where their family hangs out. I love that you used the word “natural.” That’s usually how I figure out where toys should live, by noticing where kids actually play with them.
I see this a lot with parents who work from home. Their kids keep wandering into the office, and it’s hard to get anything done. But keeping them out completely can feel like rejection to a child. So sometimes we’ll set up a little “office” basket by the desk with things like a calculator, envelopes, stamps, or a workbook. The child gets to sit nearby and “work” too. And once that’s part of the routine, a lot of kids are happy to head off and play on their own after a while.
Small changes in where things are kept can make a big difference in how they get used. That brings me to the next question: what’s your perspective on organizing toys, and how can parents tell what works for their child?
Sinem: This one feels very individual to me.
My son likes rules and clear systems. I would not describe him as extremely tidy, but his things need to have a place. If they do not, he can genuinely forget where he put them.
I am a little different. I can have something that looks messy from the outside, but I still know exactly where everything is. That pile has a place. That object belongs there. The system makes sense to me.
So I would not judge a child’s organization only by how neat it looks. I would ask a simpler question: does the child know where to find things? Can they use the space easily? If yes, there may already be a system there, even if it looks different from an adult one.
Ann: I prioritize function first, then aesthetics. I’d also add: does it work for the people the child shares the space with? A system that makes sense to one child may not work for a sibling in the same room. Coming up with something that meets the needs of everyone sharing a space is a way to practice respect and flexibility.
Of course, sharing a space also means there’s only so much room for everyone’s things. So when it comes time to declutter, which decisions are helpful for a child to make on their own, and when is it helpful for a parent to get involved?
Sinem: I think this question becomes easier for me if I separate the decision from the support around the decision.
When something belongs to the child, I think the child should usually make the final decision. The parent’s role is to stay close enough to understand what is behind that choice.
Children can make very emotional decisions, especially about objects. That does not make the decision meaningless. But sometimes they need an adult to help them think through it. Not to replace the decision, but to bring in another layer.
So I would ask questions. Why do you want to keep this? Do you still use it? Does it remind you of something? Would you miss it if it was gone?
For me, the parent can bring the thinking. The child can still keep the ownership.
Ann: In my sessions, I also let the space set the limit. If a shelf is so full that putting things away is a struggle every night, children can see for themselves why editing their collection helps. The decision becomes about what fits, not about a parent saying no.
What I see over and over in homes is that the friction usually isn’t really about the toys. It’s about the relationship. And I notice that in every answer, you’ve honored the child’s needs and feelings first.
So my last question is, what would you say to a parent who has been making all the decisions and is facing power struggles at home? Why does it matter for a child to feel their space is truly theirs, and what’s one small change that can help?
Sinem: I think a child needs to feel that their space carries some trace of them.
That can be very simple. Choosing where something goes. Putting their own drawings on the wall. Deciding how a shelf is used. Moving things around. Having a corner that looks the way they want it to look.
For me, the important part is asking for their ideas and then actually allowing those ideas to change the space.
A child’s room can be beautifully designed by an adult and still feel like a room they are only living in. I would rather see some choices that I would not have made myself, but know that the child had a hand in making the space theirs.
Ann: We both believe in including children when it comes to deciding what to do with their toys. The process may move a bit slower, but the long-term impact is worth the effort and patience.
So when a parent asks me to schedule the toy session while the kids are out, I now suggest we start somewhere else: with the parent’s own things. When parents finish their own work first, they build the confidence and skill to guide their children through the same decisions, without making those decisions for them.
When children learn to choose with confidence and feel their parents’ trust and respect, the home starts to feel like it truly belongs to everyone in it, with fewer power struggles along the way. Thanks so much, Sinem, for sharing your valuable insights.
If you enjoyed Sinem’s perspective, I hope you’ll visit her Substack, Designer.Researcher.Mother, where she shares weekly notes on children, toys, and everyday life through all three lenses.
Want support bringing your kids into the process?
If toys are just one place where home feels like a constant tug-of-war, I’d love to hear about it. I help families create homes that work for parents and children alike, organizing with kids instead of for them. Book a free 15-minute Connection Call with me.




I’m definitely feeling a lot of power struggles at home with my three-year-old toddler. I’m giving her a lot of grace because there’s a lot of transition at the moment, she’s starting preschool, which is huge for her. But she’s acting like an absolute monster. I have two kids and I’m at home with them most of the time because my partner works very long hours. And I find it hard to discipline her when I have the baby. My best parenting technique is to distract, but when I say something for the 50th time, I get really frustrated and I raise my voice. And I hate that. Is this just a phase?